REVIEW PAPER
Liability of members of the medical profession for failure to render assistance to road accident victims in polish criminal law
| 1 | Department of Substantive Criminal Law, Faculty of Law and Administration, University of Warmia and Mazury in Olsztyn, Poland |
| 2 | Department of Public Health, Hygiene and Epidemiology, Faculty of Medical Sciences, University of Warmia and Mazury in Olsztyn, Poland |
CORRESPONDING AUTHOR
Kamil Frąckowiak
Department of Substantive Criminal Law, Faculty of Law and Administration of the University of Warmia and Mazury, Warszawska 98, 10-900 Olsztyn, Poland. Tel.: +48 509954574; fax: +48 89 5236176.
Department of Substantive Criminal Law, Faculty of Law and Administration of the University of Warmia and Mazury, Warszawska 98, 10-900 Olsztyn, Poland. Tel.: +48 509954574; fax: +48 89 5236176.
Submission date: 2013-01-25
Acceptance date: 2013-07-08
Online publication date: 2013-07-09
Publication date: 2020-04-07
Pol. Ann. Med. 2013;20(1):77–81
KEYWORDS
ABSTRACT
Introduction:
In Poland the most common causes of death from several years include cardiovascular diseases, cancers and injuries, among which the most numerous are road traffic injuries. It becomes essential to have the knowledge on how to behave in case of a traffic collision. On the other hand, criminal law needs to ensure protection of human life and health from the omission of effective assistance by bystanders. A common duty to rescue and immediately notify emergency response centers is in accordance with the Act of 8 September 2006 on the State Emergency Medical Services.
Aim:
The aim of this work was to present principles of criminal liability of members of the medical profession for failure to render assistance to road accident victims.
Material and methods:
Legal-dogmatic interpretation of the law in force in Poland was provided through the prism of Supreme Court rulings and literature.
Discussion:
In Polish criminal law there is no provision that would directly apply to criminal liability of perpetrator for omission to render emergency first aid. Any criminal liability of a person not rendering first aid is based on general principles. It may be based on two provisions of Art. 162 of the Criminal Code and Art. 93 of the Petty Offence Code.
Conclusions:
Every citizen, in accordance with current law, has an obligation to assist first aid to a person in a state of imminent danger threatening the loss of life or serious bodily injury. The possibilities of derogation from the obligation to render assistance to a road accident victim are few, they comprise a closed list. Members of the medical profession (i.e. physician, nurse or paramedic) cannot refuse help to a person in a state of extreme urgency and threatening an immediate danger of loss of life and serious injury, unless rendering assistance poses a risk to health or life of their own.
In Poland the most common causes of death from several years include cardiovascular diseases, cancers and injuries, among which the most numerous are road traffic injuries. It becomes essential to have the knowledge on how to behave in case of a traffic collision. On the other hand, criminal law needs to ensure protection of human life and health from the omission of effective assistance by bystanders. A common duty to rescue and immediately notify emergency response centers is in accordance with the Act of 8 September 2006 on the State Emergency Medical Services.
Aim:
The aim of this work was to present principles of criminal liability of members of the medical profession for failure to render assistance to road accident victims.
Material and methods:
Legal-dogmatic interpretation of the law in force in Poland was provided through the prism of Supreme Court rulings and literature.
Discussion:
In Polish criminal law there is no provision that would directly apply to criminal liability of perpetrator for omission to render emergency first aid. Any criminal liability of a person not rendering first aid is based on general principles. It may be based on two provisions of Art. 162 of the Criminal Code and Art. 93 of the Petty Offence Code.
Conclusions:
Every citizen, in accordance with current law, has an obligation to assist first aid to a person in a state of imminent danger threatening the loss of life or serious bodily injury. The possibilities of derogation from the obligation to render assistance to a road accident victim are few, they comprise a closed list. Members of the medical profession (i.e. physician, nurse or paramedic) cannot refuse help to a person in a state of extreme urgency and threatening an immediate danger of loss of life and serious injury, unless rendering assistance poses a risk to health or life of their own.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
None declared.
REFERENCES (16)
1.
Bafia J, Mioduski K, Siewierski M. Kodeks karny – komentarz [Criminal Code – commentary]. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Prawnicze; 123.
2.
Komenda Główna, Policji Biuro, Ruchu Drogowego. Wydział Profilaktyki i Analiz. Wypadki drogowe w Polsce 2009 roku [Road accidents in Poland in 2009] Warszawa; 2010.
3.
Kulesza J. Źródła obowiązku gwaranta a odpowiedzialność karna lekarza za zaniechanie pomocy [Sources of obligation of the guarantor and criminal liability of a physician for failure to render assistance. Prawo Med. 2008;30(1):14–25. Accessed 12.1.13 〈www.prawoimedycyna.pl/?str=art....
4.
GDDKiA. Podstawowe statystyki wypadków drogowych na zamiejskiej sieci dróg krajowych w roku 2010 [Basic statistics of road accidents in the non-urban road network in 2010]. 2011. Accessed 12.01.13.
5.
Marek A. Kodeks karny. Komentarz [Criminal code. Commentary]. Warszawa: Wolters Kluwer; 330.
6.
Ustawa z dnia 23 kwietnia 1964 r. Kodeks cywilny (Dz.U. z 1964 r. Nr 16, poz. 93 ze zm.) [The Act of 23 April 1964 of the Civil Code (Journal of Laws of 1964 No. 16, item 93 with amendments)].
7.
Ustawa z dnia 6 czerwca 1997 r. Kodeks karny (Dz.U. z 1997 r. Nr 88, poz. 553 ze zm.) [The Act of 6 June 1997 of the Criminal Code (Journal of Laws of 1997 No. 88, item 553 with amendments)].
8.
Ustawa z dnia 20 maja 1971 r. Kodeks wykroczeń (tekst jednolity: Dz.U z 2010 r. Nr 46, poz. 275 ze zm.) [The Act of 20 May 1971 of the Petty Offence Code (uniform text: Journal of Laws of 2010 No. 46, item 275 with amendements)].
9.
Ustawa z dnia 8 września 2006 r. o Państwowym Ratownictwie Medycznym (Dz.U. z 2006 r. Nr 191, poz. 1410 ze zm.) [The Act of 8 September 2006 on the State Emergency Medical Service (Journal of Laws of 2006 No. 191, item 1410 with amendements)].
10.
Ustawa z dnia 20 czerwca 1997 r. Prawo o ruchu drogowym (tekst jednolity: Dz.U. z 2012 r. poz. 1137) [The Act of 20 June 1997 of the Law on Road Traffuc (Journal of Laws of 2012, item 1137)].
11.
Wąsek A, Zawłocki R. Kodeks karny. Cz˛eść szczególna. Komentarz do artykułów 117–221 [Criminal Code. Commentary on articles 117–221], Vol. 1. 4th ed. Warszawa: CH Beck; 2010.
12.
Wyrok SA (Kraków) z 23 czerwca 1994 r., II AKr 56/94. KZS. 1994; 6–8: poz. 53 [Judgment of the Court of Appeal (Cracov) from June 23, 1994].
13.
Wyrok SN z 28 kwietnia 1999 r., V KKN 318/99. OSPriP. 2000; 12: poz. 6 [Judgment of the Supreme Court from April 28, 1999].
14.
Wyrok SN z 5 października 1976 r., VI KRN 233/76. OSNKW. 1977; 1–2: poz. 8 [Judgment of the Supreme Court from October 5, 1976].
15.
Wyrok SN z 28 kwietnia 2000 r., V KKN 318/99. OSPriP. 2000; 12: poz. 6 [Judgment of the Supreme Court from April 28, 2000].
16.
Żaba J, Świderski P, Żaba Z, Marcinkowski JT, Podlewski R, Kołowski J. Aspekty prawno-medyczne udzielania pierwszej pomocy ofiarom wypadków drogowych [Legal and medical aspects of first aid to victims of road accidents]. Orzecz Lek. 2011;8(2):94.
RELATED ARTICLE
